Tuesday, 12 May 2009

On BBC coverage of the British National Party

As a Labour Party supporter I would like to play devil’s advocate as we all recognise that internal party debate is important.

We have a long established tradition of neutrality and impartiality in the broadcast media in this country – in contrast to print journalism and, notably American TV Networks (Fox News anyone?) I do not believe that the BBC would be fulfilling any public service by attacking the BNP. In fact, I think it would be welcomed by the ‘Fascists’. They love being underdogs and unpopular because it allows them to position themselves between ‘ordinary folk’ on one side, and the ‘old gang’ (the three major parties) as they put it, on the other. At best the BNP would denounce the BBC as ‘Marxist’ if they were attacked on air. At worst, they could turn it into a propaganda coup by telling their potential voters that the BBC are running scared because the BNP are the only party committed to doing what they promise in manifestos. Either way, they could paint the BBC as nothing more than an arm of the state used to smear the enemies of the sitting government. This is something that I am totally against regardless of the party.

I think the BBC needs to be respected for its impartiality. Louis Theroux does this magnificently for the corporation. In his time as a documentary maker he has interviewed black nationalists, white nationalists and even Baptists who said that deaths the Iraq War was divine retribution for America’s tolerance of homosexuality. Not once in any of these documentaries has Theroux passed any form of judgement on these clearly obnoxious individuals or their ideas. However, through clever questioning he has enabled Joe Public make an informed and enlightened opinion. Such opinions are much more powerful if they are formed by the individual. If the BBC teaches us to hate the BNP it becomes superficial.

We are all ‘liberals’ with a small ‘l’. John Stuart Mill taught us to give a platform to lies because under public scrutiny, or ‘the court of public opinion’ as it is these days called, they will quickly fall apart. It is far more effective to show the BNP for who they are and their questionable ideologies will fall apart well before June 4. Engage in ‘mud slinging’ and the BNP will only throw it back with much greater vigour.


The above post was in response to a letter to the BBC written by local Labour Party activist Kevin Peel:

I am shocked, disgusted and sickened at your coverage of the BNP on prime time news. It is bad enough that they get the oxygen of publicity at all, but your report was not even close to strong enough on attacking their policies of hatred, fear and division.

Impartiality can only go so far - when you are giving credence and legitimacy to a racist, homophobic, fascist party who would see homosexuality re-criminalised, non-white Britons deported and have rioting on the streets of this country, you are at best guilty of complicity in incitement to hatred and at worst positively promoting fascism.

I object in the strongest possible manner to my license money being spent in such a way and I would plead that you at least try to apply the same scrutiny to this bunch of monsters as you do to other political parties. Surely preventing fascism from rising in Britain is more important than the amount our MPs are spending on accommodation?

Sunday, 10 May 2009

21st Century Breakdown

I remember when the last Green Day album was released. Monday 20th September 2004 was the first day of Fresher's Week. Back in those hazy days I lived in Woolton Hall in Fallowfield and remember strutting down to Sainsburys to purchase my copy of American Idiot. I'd already seen Green Day the summer before; this had prorbably been one of the last opportunities anyone had had to see GD again before they achieved a 'renaissance' with what was a very accomplished Grammy award winning concept album.

I think Green Day fans fall into two camps - those who were fans before 2004 and those who have become fans afterwards. I must say I liked the new experimentation on American Idiot and the opportunities it afforded the band to produce an ever more expansive live show (I've seen them twice since, once at the MK Bowl, and they were fantastic on both occasions). However, like many I long for a return to the Insomniac days of angst and three-chord driven punk energy.

I don't have a lot of time for those who say that Green Day 'weren't punk' in the 90s. Anyone who expects 90s punks to sound like their 70s counterpart seriously misunderestimate the evolution of music. Insomniac was a dark, disturbing album based on issues such as drugs, panic attacks, depression and boredom. 'Masturbation' has become the watchword for Dookie-era GD - the truth is that it was merely 'alluded to' on one song on album. No, GD of the 90s was proper punk, not quite as hardcore as Rancid - but with just as many credentials and passion. Both bands grew out of the California punk circuit. Yes, Green Day played to 5 kids, they carried their own amps around in a van and sang about everyday life. They did it the proper way.

GD had always been political. 2000s 'Minority' was a sign of things to come and by the time American Idiot came around I was happy because I had always been impressed by their ability to stay ahead of the game at a time when Sum 41 was churning out second rate versions of GD songs from 5-7 years previously. The new grandiose statements and Springsteen-influenced ballads and pianos fitted perfectly with BJ's skills as a show man - a modern day Freddie Mercury and a man whose energy on stage went some way to explaining why his rounder frame had seemed to disappear.

Over the last week I have been listening to 21st Century Breakdown. The last GD material I'd listened to was their alter-ego offering 'Stop drop and roll' (Foxboro Hot Tubs). Although in a chugging 50s garage rock style, this record offered a hint that the insomniac days were returning. However, what we get with 21BD is a more ambitious, dare I say it *better* version of AI. The pianos and melodies are there a plenty. As talented as GB and BJ may be, I can think of few other artists who sport as many creative influences - Clash, Springsteen, Beatles - they're all here. In fact, one song - Horseshoes and Handgrenades sounds *far* too similar to Main Offender by the Hives. Nevertheless I certainly think that the lyrics put GD into a league of their own and are better than AI:

American Eulogy, part a) Mass Hysteria

Red alert is the color of panic
elevated to the point of static
beating into the hearts of the fanatics
and the neighborhood's a loaded gun
Idle thought leads to full-throttle screaming
and the welfare is asphyxiating
Mass confusion is all the new rage
and it's creating a feeding ground
for the bottom feeders of hysteria

American Eulogy is my favourite song on the album - probably because it reminds me of a more ambitious 'Westbound Sign' from Insomniac. Looking at it this way and considering the range and lyrical improvements that have been made you would expect it to be a much better album than 1995s. I don't think it's quite as simple as that. 21BD is a great album, it will become a great addition to the back catalogue and will once again confirm GD's position musically - nevertheless, I think that it will still leave old fans unsatisfied. GD have built a new genre for themselves - 'stadium punk', the days of small sweaty moshing to Platypus (I have you) or Jaded seem to be over. Bands grow up, I just home that when I see them for the fourth time in October that they find time for these early punk classics, because what I'm hearing today, however great it is, just ain't punk, despite the lyrical quality.

Monday, 20 April 2009

Happy Birthday

I have just noticed that this is my first anniversary as a member of the blogging community. Despite my paltry efforts (38 posts in 365 days), I'm glad that I've been able to communicate some of my musings in this way. Some have been, admittedly, rather inconsequential; others a bit more substantial - take for example my first post on the BNP in Carlisle. What I've never attempted to be here is a 'serious blogger' - I neither have the time, inclination or skills to become the next 'Guido Fawkes'. However, I do enjoy sitting down and typing what I think. One thing is clear to me - next year, if I teach AS level politics again, I'm going to set up a blogging community for my pupils. This will take debate out of the classroom in into pupils bedrooms and, to use teacher-y jargon 'extend their learning in an out of classroom context.' Nice; anway enough self congratulation..

Recent sign-ups

I sit here, on the cusp of another time at the mighty Crompton House, contemplating two things to which I have signed up.

The first, Spotify - is something that I'm listening to now. To be precise I'm listening to Sky Larkin - a band that I like but as yet do not own the album. *Cut to the chase Craig* Ahem, Spotify is a simple download which provides unlimited access to all the music you could ever want at the touch of a button. Two simple catches - you can't download the songs (but why would you need to - you can listen again and again) and the music is punctuated with occasional adverts, Iggy Pop trying to sell me insurance during the middle of Ladyhawke. Considering the price, this is hardly worth grumbling about. The great thing is that it allows you to listen to albums in full before you decide whether you want to buy them. Sweet! And it's fookin' fast!

Second, LoveFilm. I've heard a lot about this - most of it good. On a recent visit to my cousin in Newcastle (she's pregnant finally!) I noticed that her and Mike were devotees. They couldn't praise it highly enough - you choose the films, they post it, you keep it for as long as you want (you can't get another until it's returned) and the envelope converts into an SAE for easy posting back.

I've cashed my 30 day free trial and order my first film - the Baader-Meinhof Complex. The only downside is that watching them can become a chore - something else to 'fit in; - we;ll see, I'll give it a go...

Tuesday, 24 March 2009

While I've got five minutes...

Jade Goody

...died on Saturday from that most devastating of illnesses, cancer. It is a horrendous way to go - I saw my nana's decline over the space of three months and it wasn't pretty. By the end, sufferers are shadow of their former selves at it's so difficult for relatives who are trying to remember loved ones as they were. Even more tragic is the fact that Jade was 27 - a mere sproglet!

Quite a lot has been made about Jade's reality TV star status. She came third in Big Brother in 2002 at the age of 21 and has since spent her whole adult life in front of the camera in one form or another. Over the years, I, like many people have deplored these pointless celebrities - individuals who are famous for no particular reason. However, with her passing I am feeling as bit more melancholy so I will say this. For the daughter of a one-armed heroin addict from a council estate to experience the sort of success that she has is nothing less than extraordinary. Throughout the later years of her short life, people constantly commented on the fact that she was 'one of us' - not a trumped up Victoria Beckham 'lite' with a supposed air of superiority. Even when she uttered racist comments to Shilpa Shetty in 2007 she merely reflected the intolerance and bigotted attitudes which I'm sorry to say characterise large swathes of our society.

Of course, it's a breath of fresh air to see someone who wasn't born with a silver spoon in their mouth making it 'big', albeit for no discerable reason - there is something seemingly democratic about that...it certainly wouldn't have happened 30 years ago and now that Jade's plight has led to a multiplication in cervival cancer smear tests, her family can at least take some comfort from the fact that she has a legacy other than being the first individual to take the reality TV 'bull' by the proverbial 'horns'. RIP Jade Goody!

Thursday, 12 March 2009

Islamists - it's a shame a disturbing ideology is named after the world's greatest religion..

The other day a group of Islamists protested as soldiers returning from Iraq paraded in their own town. The most disturbing thing about this is the olive branch that it offers to the British National Party - all Muslims preach hate, all are unpatriotic, all would blow up 'our boys' givin half the chance etc..etc..

Fortunately, most people are educated enough to realise that the policy of a national government merely reflects where the army *goes*. These chaps who 'hate Jews' because of the policies of the Israeli government fall into a similar category. Soldiers are individuals with heads - they can think what they want, however they have a duty, a much more basically - they are doing a job. Furthermore, take politics out everything and at the end of the day these folks are doing a very tough job - the threat of being blown up, suicide bombings and mines are often matched by acts of extreme bravery. I can only imagine how pissed off those soldiers must have been. These Islamists represent a minority whose obnoxious views are as nauseating as their enemies in the BNP. Maybe these guys should team up - surely they could find some common ground. Oh, I've found some: H.A.T.E That's what these guys are pretty good at disseminating - hate is hate, i.e., neither black, nor white.

Hey, what am I talking about - they've already done this, well rhetorically anyway when it comes to the new spread in antisemitism. Quite a few Anglicans have jumped on the bandwagon too...oh, how I do like a good 'love-in' by the forces of evil - and herein this reflection has descended into a rant so I'll end it ..now..

Friday, 20 February 2009

An eerie vision of the future?

At the second attempt I have finally got round to finishing P. D. James' 'The Children of Men'. I first tried to read it about 18 months ago. It's not a 'hard' book, it's just something that happens to me sometimes. I read in 'waves'. Last year was particularly productive. I must have read about 20 books and they were all quite a reasonable length too. I hit a literary 'wall' though a couple of months ago when reading 'The Audacity of Hope'. Christmas should have freed up time for reading but I was probably too busy eating and drinking. Nevermind, with February on the horizon I polished off Barack's sanitized vision for America (see previous post) and ploughed into dystopia.

I am quite a big fan of the genre. I enjoyed Nineteen Eighty-Four, Brave New World and A Clockwork Orange. Next on the list is A Handmaid's Tale. Anyway, back to the point...The Children of Men is set in 2021, 25 years after the last human baby has been born. Civilisation is slowly dying out because of man's failure to successfully deal with it's own destruction of the environment. As a result most people are apathetic and parliamentary democracy has been brushed aside, along with most vestiges of liberty in favour of the despotic rule of Xan Lyppiatt - brother of the novel's protagonist Theo Faron. Faron is an Oxford Don who is contacted by a group of freedom fighters called the 'Five Fishes'. Initially pessimistic, he is soon won over when it is revealed that one of the fishes (Julian - a woman who was christened incorrectly!) is pregnant - the first in 25 years. The rest is basically a 'road-book' (is there such a phrase? I'm looking for the literary equivalent of 'road movie') where the main characters attempt to escape the clutches of the State Security Police (SSP) and find a suitable place for Julian to give birth. Along the way, the other fishes are killed under various circumstances, Theo eventually faces Xan, shoots him and the novel ends with the baby healthy and Faron about to become the new 'Warden of England'. All in all, a great novel - it's strongest quality is the overall premise of a dying world simply because of all the questions this throws up. What do previously religious people now think of God? Are we still duty bound to obey the law? At what point do we cross the 'boundary' and return to a Hobbesian/Lockean state of nature? To what extent should liberty be sacrificed under these circumstances? Exciting stuff!

I am now reading 'Birds without Wings' by Louis de Bernieres - a recommendation by James both because of its subject matter (WW1) and the fact that it is set in Turkey - a country that I will be visiting in August.

I perhaps ought to briefly mention the bands and films that I have seen recently. Let's start with Bloc Party..I managed to get standing tickets for myself and Dougie, Head of Geography, back in January. So we rolled up - Wednesday night, and had a thoroughly cracking time. The band were note perfect, the drummer sublime and overall they're well worthy of their position as one of Britain's foremost indie bands. What I couldn't understand was why people would pay to go to a gig only to throw glow sticks at them? The crowd was a bit 'impotent' to say the least - maybe because it was mid-week. Nevertheless, the two encores were well received. On the second occasion we were outside when we heard the first few bars of 'Flux' and had to race back in. It really was a great song to finish off with and sounds so much better live, partly I suspect because they have less technology to rely on.

Just over a week later me and James went to see the NME Shockwaves tour. I wanted to go so I could see a band that I have really 'discovered' this past few months. White Lies are from West London and play Joy Division/Interpol/Editors inspired post punk. The singer, like his forbears, sports a baritone voice and their own tunes are a bit poppier than previous incarnations - think The Killers. Nevertheless, I thought they were fantastic even though the keyboard packed up half way through the set.

Florence and the Machine were also on the bill. I'd never heard of them and it's always a pleasant surprise to see a band live for the first time and to actually like them. Florence has a cracking voice and I will look forward to the album. She came back on stage during the White Lies set to duet with the lead singer and it was absolutely fantastic.

The least said about Friendly Fires the better. James was really up for seeing Glasvegas. I can't say that I'm a fan. It sounds horrible I know but the strong Scottish accents really grate on me. Although to be honest it's probably the triumphalist and over the top nature of their melodies that doesn't really appeal either.

Last Thursday we went to see Secret Machines. This was a completely different experience altogther. The gig was at the intimate 'Ruby Lounge' near the Arndale and it was pretty impressive to see this 3-piece here given that they've supported Interpol and played the Academy. Anyway, they place a Pink Floyd-prog rock inspired blend of rock, punk and metal. Anyway you say it, it's pretty 'deep'. Average song length is about 10 minutes - they probably only played about 7 songs in over an hour. All in all they were pretty impressive. All prior assumptions regarding the volume levels that three guys could produce were brushed aside. This band was loud!!

I'm getting a wee bit tired of typing now - I'll finish by saying that two films I have seen recently have really impressed me. It goes without saying that Slumdog Millionaire is good, excellent in fact. I was also impressed by Frost/Nixon by its ability to turn an interview, albeit a high profile one, into an intruiging political thriller. It has ignited my interest in the Watergate scandal and the Nixon presidency in particular. This bodes well considering that it appears that I'll be teaching this at A2 Level next year. Yipes! :-)