The Beeb has long been regarded as ever so slightly left of centre. When all is said and done it is a nationalised industry. The Daily Mail has been criticising Auntie for this as long as I can remember and to be honest the Corporation's recent actions over Gaza and the DEC has done little to alter the impression.
Ironically, the BBC decided not to screen the DEC appeal because it feared that it could be regarded as biased reporting. By making this decision however, controversially it should be added, it has 'become the news' rather than being the body who reports on it. This conscious desire to distance itself from the Palastinians could be seen, by cynics, as tacit acceptance of hitherto partisan reporting. The Corporation has been criticised even more lately, however, with Gazans effectively 'ghettoized' and pummelled into submission by the military might of Israel (backed up by the US), who can blame them?
Nevertheless, the BBC has not done itself any favours by tying itself in knots over this issue. I think that it would have been better to show the appeal and then use opportunity afforded by Holocaust Memorial Day in order to restate the case for the existence of the state of Israel. Now that would have been balanced reporting...
Monday, 26 January 2009
Tuesday, 20 January 2009
President Obama
After the longest election campaign in history, Barack Obama was finally elected as the 44th President of the United States today. After blogging roughly a year ago that I believed it was all but over for him (the loss of the New Hampshire Primary seemed to hand the initiative back to Hillary Clinton), the Civil Rights ovement has finally come full circle. I feel so full of hyperbole that I'm feeling a little big speechless to be honest. I listened to the inauguration on Radio 4 in a gym car park in Royton (that's what I'll tell my grandkids). Uncharacteristically, Obama fluffed his lines (who can blame him!) before giving another flawless and rousing inaugural speech. The BBC news media correctly pointed out the almost regal air surrounding the day. Hmmmm. To best honest that's just about as much as I can manage :)
Sunday, 18 January 2009
Balanced Broadcasting?
This is not the first time I have been angry at the media because of their unbalanced portrayal of disasters when it involves America. 18 months ago I ranted against the media for their coverage of forest fires in California merely on account of the fact it threatened the homes of some of the Hollywood rich and famous. This time disaster was averted and the media still went mad.
Now don't get me wrong, the safe landing of the US Airlines flight into the Hudson river was nothing short of a miracle. The captain deserves to be called a hero and commended for his professionalism. However, did we really need wall to wall coverage for nearly 72 hours? Plane crashes in other countries which result in fatalities numbering in the hundreds do not get nearly this much coverage. Forty Iraqis died in Baghdad in a suicide bombing the other week and it didn't even reach the news headlines.
America will be in the news for all the right reasons this week. It will inaugurate its first black president on Tuesday. I will watch this coverage with pride - the news media may go over the top but when something like this happens it doesn't quite seem to matter. At least we don't live IN America - according to the John Stewart show, the major networks tied themselves in knots contemplating what Sasha and Malia would be having for their school dinners now they have moved to Washington.
Now don't get me wrong, the safe landing of the US Airlines flight into the Hudson river was nothing short of a miracle. The captain deserves to be called a hero and commended for his professionalism. However, did we really need wall to wall coverage for nearly 72 hours? Plane crashes in other countries which result in fatalities numbering in the hundreds do not get nearly this much coverage. Forty Iraqis died in Baghdad in a suicide bombing the other week and it didn't even reach the news headlines.
America will be in the news for all the right reasons this week. It will inaugurate its first black president on Tuesday. I will watch this coverage with pride - the news media may go over the top but when something like this happens it doesn't quite seem to matter. At least we don't live IN America - according to the John Stewart show, the major networks tied themselves in knots contemplating what Sasha and Malia would be having for their school dinners now they have moved to Washington.
Tuesday, 30 December 2008
Ignorance isn't bliss
Four days in, Israel continue to blast Gaza and the international community deplores it with some reservations. America in particular has made no effort to condemn the Israelis who are acting perhaps in coordination with the last days of the Bush presidency. Obama may not be so accomodating.
Let's be clear about this. I think Israel is using an excessive amount of force. As expected, Israeli embassies around the globe were inundated with protesters, not least London which became a target for the SWP, Respect and the loony lefties brigade. One placard made me see red, and I'm not talking about the kind of red that calls for 'full nationalisation *hand wiggle*' - T. Benn. No, this was something much more deplorable.
'Stop the Holocaust in Gaza'
Comparing the military assault on Gaza, no matter how bad it is, with the systematic mechanical slaughter of an entire race of people is one of the most reprehensible things I have ever read. Not only does it stick two fingers up to 6 million murdered people and their descendants and survivors, but it completely confuses what is going on in Gaza with what we mean by the term 'Holocaust'. Any academic will tell you that this means 'burnt sacrifice' and is a very specific term used to describe the decimation of the Jewish race in Europe between 1933 and 1945. I doubt that many Arabs in Gaza would like to know that their plight is being described with the same word. Furthermore, whilst it is wrong to make a 'comparison of pain' argument, I do not feel that we are not into the realms of genocide just yet. Israeli behaviour at the moment is abhorrent - just as it is to describe it as the start of a 'Holocaust'. There is only one event in history that can be described using this word.
Let's be clear about this. I think Israel is using an excessive amount of force. As expected, Israeli embassies around the globe were inundated with protesters, not least London which became a target for the SWP, Respect and the loony lefties brigade. One placard made me see red, and I'm not talking about the kind of red that calls for 'full nationalisation *hand wiggle*' - T. Benn. No, this was something much more deplorable.
'Stop the Holocaust in Gaza'
Comparing the military assault on Gaza, no matter how bad it is, with the systematic mechanical slaughter of an entire race of people is one of the most reprehensible things I have ever read. Not only does it stick two fingers up to 6 million murdered people and their descendants and survivors, but it completely confuses what is going on in Gaza with what we mean by the term 'Holocaust'. Any academic will tell you that this means 'burnt sacrifice' and is a very specific term used to describe the decimation of the Jewish race in Europe between 1933 and 1945. I doubt that many Arabs in Gaza would like to know that their plight is being described with the same word. Furthermore, whilst it is wrong to make a 'comparison of pain' argument, I do not feel that we are not into the realms of genocide just yet. Israeli behaviour at the moment is abhorrent - just as it is to describe it as the start of a 'Holocaust'. There is only one event in history that can be described using this word.
Sunday, 28 December 2008
Bombing Gaza
I was watching the ever proficient Channel 4 news program last night. The main news story was Israel's air assault on the Gaza strip - an attack that comes at the end of a six month ceasefire (during which I was fortunate to visit the area). The presenter talked to the Israeli defence minister (I forget his name) and started by questioning his motives for the attack. He said that Hamas had been firing missiles for weeks and were a direct threat to southern Israel. Fair enough. Here's my problem..
He was then asked what Israel's future military strategy would be in the next few days. The minister did not want to reveal this for security reasons (fair enough) but also because the future military intervention depended 'on the reaction of Hamas and the Palestinians'...I'm pretty sure that this reaction is not going to be anything other than an armed retaliation.
Israel is a sovereign state entitled to defend its borders. Fact. Israel deserves to exist as a state in its own right. Fact. However, yesterday's act of brutality serves no other purpose other than to escalate the level of violence in the area. No doubt in the next few days Palestinian suicide bombers will attack Israel's major cities. Whilst I will not be able to excuse such activity I will have no problem questioning their motivation. The Israelis need to realise that you can only achieve so much diplomatically through the barrel of a gun. The genius who thinks that airstrikes will solve the problems of the Middle East needs his head looking at.
Furthermore (and this is my real 'bugbear'), when future military plans are based on the reaction of the other side you are giving tacit assumption to the fact that the other side will respond violently. This is ok during a state of war, however, the Middle Eastern countries were not 'at war' last time I heard. Israel is trying to administer a 'peace process' with F16 fighter jets. This will not work.
He was then asked what Israel's future military strategy would be in the next few days. The minister did not want to reveal this for security reasons (fair enough) but also because the future military intervention depended 'on the reaction of Hamas and the Palestinians'...I'm pretty sure that this reaction is not going to be anything other than an armed retaliation.
Israel is a sovereign state entitled to defend its borders. Fact. Israel deserves to exist as a state in its own right. Fact. However, yesterday's act of brutality serves no other purpose other than to escalate the level of violence in the area. No doubt in the next few days Palestinian suicide bombers will attack Israel's major cities. Whilst I will not be able to excuse such activity I will have no problem questioning their motivation. The Israelis need to realise that you can only achieve so much diplomatically through the barrel of a gun. The genius who thinks that airstrikes will solve the problems of the Middle East needs his head looking at.
Furthermore (and this is my real 'bugbear'), when future military plans are based on the reaction of the other side you are giving tacit assumption to the fact that the other side will respond violently. This is ok during a state of war, however, the Middle Eastern countries were not 'at war' last time I heard. Israel is trying to administer a 'peace process' with F16 fighter jets. This will not work.
Tuesday, 23 December 2008
2008 Round Up
In many ways, 2008 has been a hectic year for me. In short, the position I find myself in this December - living in Manchester in living in that mythical alternative universe commonly referred to by parents and, notably, Morpheus as 'the real world', bares little comparison to my status back in January.
Twelve months ago I had three weeks to run in my first teaching practice school in Keswick - heart of the Lake District. I have many fond memories of that school and remember not wanting to leave as I felt 'in my stride' and refreshed after the Christmas break. However, a return to university loomed at the end of the month and I settled in to being a 'student' for the very last time. This of course meant mid week drinking, getting up late and working when I dictated. Happy days.
So, after a couple of weeks which included an axciting excursion to Manchester for a research project on Bangladeshi migrants (this included a personal investigation into the whereabouts of a deported migrant by the name of Vinod Chauan in 1984. It was interesting to read first hand the insitutional racism which existed within tghe GMP at the time), I returned to Carlisle for my 11 week stint at the now defunct St. Aidan's Comprehensive School. Like gruelling army exercises of my youth it was one of those experiences that you didn't realise that you enjoyed until well afterwards. Although i wasn't involved directly in any confrontation, it was one of those schools where you don't feel particularly comfortable and i often took solace from the fact that it would not be my permanent vocation. I now feel for those who are struggling to run its successor The Richard Rose and Central Academies. God help them.
Speaking of God, it was about this time that, after four failed attempts, i finally secured employment at Crompton House School back in my old stomping ground of Greater Manchester. I celebrated by embarking with James on my first ever skiing adventure, courtesy of my current housemate Christian, who at the time was a chalet manager in the glamorous resort of La Rosiere in the French Alps.
Then it was back to St. Aidans for a final 7 weeks, after which the PGCE was virtually nailed. I completed the Great Manchester run, spent two weeks working at a Labour History Archive in Salford, then jetted off round the former Yugoslavia with Lehna.
Summer was an exciting time! I went to Blackpool, Berlin and Jersusalem! - and yes it was in that particular order. All offered satisfaction in there own particular way, however a special mention needs to be given to my sorjourn to Israel where I had a truly life changing experience learning about the Holocaust and how to teach it effectively in school. At the time of writing I am intending to start an MA course in Holocaust Studies from September 2010.
Finally, I have of course been 'cutting my teeth' at Crompton House School since September, and a busy 15 weeks it has been too! Next year promises to be more straightforward, now massive changes are expected. What I want to do is become a really good teacher (there's a way to go) and with breathing space before I start my MA, after Christmas it's time to 'get really good'...Aside from that, other potential highlights include a second trip to Poland, the Battlefield tour with school in July, wherever I decide to take myself for my summer holidays and a gig in Glasgow featuring the legend that is Bob Dylan.
I'm tentatively excited...a Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year to all my readers (if any!)
:-)
Twelve months ago I had three weeks to run in my first teaching practice school in Keswick - heart of the Lake District. I have many fond memories of that school and remember not wanting to leave as I felt 'in my stride' and refreshed after the Christmas break. However, a return to university loomed at the end of the month and I settled in to being a 'student' for the very last time. This of course meant mid week drinking, getting up late and working when I dictated. Happy days.
So, after a couple of weeks which included an axciting excursion to Manchester for a research project on Bangladeshi migrants (this included a personal investigation into the whereabouts of a deported migrant by the name of Vinod Chauan in 1984. It was interesting to read first hand the insitutional racism which existed within tghe GMP at the time), I returned to Carlisle for my 11 week stint at the now defunct St. Aidan's Comprehensive School. Like gruelling army exercises of my youth it was one of those experiences that you didn't realise that you enjoyed until well afterwards. Although i wasn't involved directly in any confrontation, it was one of those schools where you don't feel particularly comfortable and i often took solace from the fact that it would not be my permanent vocation. I now feel for those who are struggling to run its successor The Richard Rose and Central Academies. God help them.
Speaking of God, it was about this time that, after four failed attempts, i finally secured employment at Crompton House School back in my old stomping ground of Greater Manchester. I celebrated by embarking with James on my first ever skiing adventure, courtesy of my current housemate Christian, who at the time was a chalet manager in the glamorous resort of La Rosiere in the French Alps.
Then it was back to St. Aidans for a final 7 weeks, after which the PGCE was virtually nailed. I completed the Great Manchester run, spent two weeks working at a Labour History Archive in Salford, then jetted off round the former Yugoslavia with Lehna.
Summer was an exciting time! I went to Blackpool, Berlin and Jersusalem! - and yes it was in that particular order. All offered satisfaction in there own particular way, however a special mention needs to be given to my sorjourn to Israel where I had a truly life changing experience learning about the Holocaust and how to teach it effectively in school. At the time of writing I am intending to start an MA course in Holocaust Studies from September 2010.
Finally, I have of course been 'cutting my teeth' at Crompton House School since September, and a busy 15 weeks it has been too! Next year promises to be more straightforward, now massive changes are expected. What I want to do is become a really good teacher (there's a way to go) and with breathing space before I start my MA, after Christmas it's time to 'get really good'...Aside from that, other potential highlights include a second trip to Poland, the Battlefield tour with school in July, wherever I decide to take myself for my summer holidays and a gig in Glasgow featuring the legend that is Bob Dylan.
I'm tentatively excited...a Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year to all my readers (if any!)
:-)
Friday, 19 December 2008
The 11 Plus
Philosophically, the defence of a selective Grammar school education is problematic, however, one recent report in the media isn't difficult to counter. It has been said that the 11 Plus, the aeons-old entrance exam which traditionally siphoned off the clever from the no-so-clever in Year 6 of primary school, has a success rate based merely on affluence.
I could use my own experience to counter this claim. The argument is that only richer families can afford the tutoring that is required for success in the test. However, what this neglects to acknowledge is the scores of families up and down the country who go through this revision procedure with their children for free, my own father being one of them. I remember in the three months or so before the exam being sat down regularly by him to sit practice papers while he did his best to explain to me the intricacies of decimals and fractions. I might also add that at no point did I do this under 'duress'. There was no pushy parenting involved (which may be the case if tuition is paid for) and it was fimly my decision about whether I took the exam in the first place.
Now I recognise that an equality of opportunity argument still exists. Theorists would argue that, although my family did not have an unfair wealth advantage, a child of my background benefitted from having a stable nuclear family. Many able pupils would never have the opportunity of a Grammar school education because they are unfortunate enough to be born into a family that does not offer the stable environment under which the preparation for the transition to Grammar school could be achieved (i.e., formative equality of opportunity).
I'll leave it to governments to achieve substantive equality of opportunity. In the meantime, it needs to be realised that money alone does not buy success.
I could use my own experience to counter this claim. The argument is that only richer families can afford the tutoring that is required for success in the test. However, what this neglects to acknowledge is the scores of families up and down the country who go through this revision procedure with their children for free, my own father being one of them. I remember in the three months or so before the exam being sat down regularly by him to sit practice papers while he did his best to explain to me the intricacies of decimals and fractions. I might also add that at no point did I do this under 'duress'. There was no pushy parenting involved (which may be the case if tuition is paid for) and it was fimly my decision about whether I took the exam in the first place.
Now I recognise that an equality of opportunity argument still exists. Theorists would argue that, although my family did not have an unfair wealth advantage, a child of my background benefitted from having a stable nuclear family. Many able pupils would never have the opportunity of a Grammar school education because they are unfortunate enough to be born into a family that does not offer the stable environment under which the preparation for the transition to Grammar school could be achieved (i.e., formative equality of opportunity).
I'll leave it to governments to achieve substantive equality of opportunity. In the meantime, it needs to be realised that money alone does not buy success.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
