Sunday, 14 December 2008

A letter of admiration

Gary Cook
Chief Executive
Manchester City Football Club

Dear Mr. Cook,

Me and my housemate live a mere half a mile from the City of Manchester stadium. For the past couple of months, during our weekly sojourn to ASDA, we have felt nothing but immense pride at the sight of the slogan ‘Pride in Battle’ which is emblazoned on the side of your stadium, or should I say ‘Theatre of War’.

When battle commences we can often hear through our window the sound of the massed ranks cheering on your heroic gladiators as they engage with the enemy. It was during one such skirmish the other week (I think it was against those dastardly axis powers, Manchester United), that I found myself watching a documentary about the Second World War. Some chap was talking about his experiences at the ‘Battle’ of Iwo Jima in 1945 (I do, of course, use the term ‘Battle’ in the loosest possible sense). He was commenting of the plight of US Marines engaged in fighting with Japanese troops and I must say I felt sorry for the poor man. He was moved to tears and I thought to myself, ‘look old man, this dilly-dallying in the Pacific does not constitute what I would call a ‘battle’. He clearly has never seen your brave fellows, Robinho and the like, engaged in battle week after week with General Mark Hughes, risking life and limb for literally pennies.

This is when I realised that there is something very wrong at the heart of our ‘broken society’. Ghurkhas receive Victoria Crosses for fannying about in Malaya in the 1960s or whenever and I’m like ‘look! Who cares, the glorious troops of Manchester City football club take pride in battle week after week and it’s not as if it’s about a few palm trees in fuzzy-wuzzy land. This is football and it’s football that matters.

Take for example the recent war in Afghanistan. I read this week that if you lose an eye in ‘combat’ you are entitled to about £45,000 in compensation from the MoD. Some people have complained about this so-called ‘meagre’ sum of money compared to, for example, footballer’s wages. Again, they miss the point. The abuse from fans that your players receive, not to mention the rigorous training they need to complete (‘Pride in Battle’ requires a great deal of preparation) makes the British army’s scraps with rag-heads in Afghanistan look like a storm in a teacup.

So, all in all I just want to say that I am extremely supportive of your slogan ‘Pride in Battle’. I think it neatly encapsulates the struggles that take place both in East Manchester and during your recent offensives in Europe. I think it is time that the Great British public accepted you all for who you are - namely national heroes, the likes of which our soldiers past and present could only dream of emulating.

I am, Sir, your obedient servant,

S. A. R. Chasm

So long TIF...

On Friday, Mancunians voted by a margin or nearly 4 10 1 (0r 79%) against the proposed congestion charge for their city and, consequently against the Transport Innovation Fund of well over a billion pounds offered by the government.

Whilst the 'No' vote is clearly disappointing, it can be easily explained:

1. The successful organisation of the 'No' campaign
2. The contrasting 'slowness' of the 'Yes' campaign and its inability to properly inform the public. For many, the congestion charge was just another 'money spinner', similar to council tax as they see it.
3. The recession. At a time when people are tightening their belts, the last thing they want is another tax on car usage. This is despite the fact that the congestion charge would not have come into force until 2013, by which time the recession would have ended and the economy would, I assume, have considerably improved.
4. By this time, the improvements to Manchester's transport infrastructure would have been completed. The public would no doubt have been slightly more willing to pay for a visible improvement.

Given the overwhelming 'No' vote, 79% of the turnout now lack the moral authority to complain about congestion in Manchester ever again. Furthermore, the risible turnout demonstrates two things, namely the failure of the 'Yes' campaign to excite the public and the failure of poorer people to vote who would, in all certainty, have benefitted from the improvements outlined by the TIF.

Maybe the charging zone was too big, maybe it was bad timing. Either way, Mancunians have missed a great opportunity to improve transport in their city.

However, given that we live in a democracy I would not propose to do what the Irish have decided re: the EU constitution. No means no; you cannot ask people to vote again because you do not like the outcome!

Monday, 8 December 2008

What does Barack really think about the death penalty?

Over the last week or so I've been reading Barack Obama's 'The Audacity of Hope' - his pitch to the American public, published 18 months or so before he ran for the highest office. Whilst so far it is a cracking book, I have been reading it with some degree of scepticism because I know that it was written by a man who wanted to run for preseident and therefore would not say anything that opposition parties could pounce upon. In other words, Obama's work has a very diplomatic air to it. Whilst he is of course a left leaning liberal, he professes his love for the US and, more importantly, fails to seriously crisitcise his opponents. The question is, is this the real Obama?

I found myself asking this question when I read the following quote:

"I believe that there are such crimes - mass murder, the rape and murder of a child - so heinous, so beyond the pale, that the community is justified in expressing the full measure of its outrage by meting out the ultimate punishment."

This standpoint contradicts everything we think we know about Obama. He was against the war in Iraq, opposes Guantanamo and all forms of torture and, in many ways, is the most left wing President-Elect since FDR. He is perhaps even further to the left. The fact that he still supports the death penalty underlines an important point about the American political system.

A talking head on Channel 4 news tonight put the point amply enough:

'You forget, this is the United States of America. You cannot run for president and be against the death penalty. The last man to do that was Michael Dukakis [1988 v Bush I] and he didn't get many votes.'

This is very true; just as Obama has had to say he supports the death penalty (a law which I suspect, deep down, he deplores), his Democratic party has courted the religious right, in both cases for the purpose of winning votes. So when an 'upstanding' Obama presents himself as a new type of politician who doesn't 'play politics' in the traditional sense (i.e., pandering to interests), he clearly does...Am I criticising Obama for this? No. In truth, he wouldn't have achieved what he has done recently has he not professed his support for the ultimate punishment.

Saturday, 6 December 2008

Festive musings

This Saturday was meant to be the day where I nailed all of my Christmas shopping. However, this was all done on Tuesday and Thursday. In the first instance school was quite rightfully cancelled. After skidding my way to work and ultimately abandoning my car due to snow and ice I arrived to find out that school was closed. Further bad weather was forcast for Thursday and we found out on Wednesday afternoon that school would be cancelled the next day. I baked, I shopped and I ran - all not in any particular order. The upshot is, I had a free Saturday.

Being recently single, I find that I have a lot more time to fill So towards the end of this week when I was contemplating how to spend my Saturday, I turned to the fantastically titled 'I never knew that about England', a book that I have seldom read since it was given to me as a gift when I left St. Aidans school.

And that's how I decided to go to York. I went there on a residential trip in 1996 when I was still at primary school. To be honest I'm not sure that I've been there since. It really is a lovely place, the shambles, carol singers and brass bands playing seasonal tunes would make it difficult for the most ardent Scrooge not to feel a wee bit festive. Having left the train my first foray was into the Oxfam book shop where I managed to buy a copy of Bagehot's 'The English Constitution'. For any political historian, or political scientist, this book, published in 1872, is THE text for understanding the development of the British political system. I don't know what particular date this one was published, but it has a particularly handsome jacket and is a very easy read - so much so that it is difficult to realise that you are actually reading mid-Victorian prose.

I also bought 'Fast Cakes' by Mary Berry. My flatmate, Christian is an avid baker and I've recently taken up the hobby, making gingerbread and scones so far. Hopefully this book will give me a few more ideas.

So, having been to the bookshop I went for a pint in a pub which I forget the name of but it was recommended in my GBG (which was safely tucked in my bag). I also went to the city gallery (and saw a fantastic painting called 'Return to the Front' - or something like that. It shows soldiers in 1916 at a train station, waiting for a return to the trenches), had fish and chips and enjoyed a directionless meander round the maze-like medieval streets. A return to Manchester made me realise how great this city is, but how it does face a shortfall in terms of character. Surely this is the price that is paid for industrialisation. Prior to the 'revolution' of 1780-1820, York was the principle city of the north. However, given that it had little involvement in the spinning and weaving industry it effectively de-industrialised and retained a relatively stable population. The same can be said for Chester - another nice city, and somewhere ripe for a visit in 2009.

Sunday, 30 November 2008

Grown Up!

Things I've done this weekend for which I could be regarded as middle aged:

1. Baked
2. Listened to Joni Mitchell
3. Ironed
4. Been to a school Christmas Fair
5. Hob-nobbed with parents while buying raffle ticket for prizes such as Baileys liqueur and Imperial Leather.
5. Been to an Art gallery
6. Cleaned the flat

This has to stop! Only three weeks to go until the Christmas break. Before that, party season is here, woo. This should reset the balance:

1. Advent house party on Canal Street
2. NQT night out
3. Manchester lash
4. School Xmas party
5. History/Geography party
6. Collette party
7. Christmas dinner at Alan Towers.

Right, off to go running, otherwise I will be the size of a house!!

Tuesday, 25 November 2008

Where's the compassion?

I recognise that this is fast becoming a 'bash the Tories' blog, however...

The Shadow Health Secretary says that a recession has its good points because people are forced to drink and smoke less.

Yes but,

They also lose their jobs,
have their homes repossessed,
find it difficult to feed their kids,
have a greater chance of developing mental disorders,
can't refuel their car,
can't get a mortgage...

The list goes on.

Are we to be surprised? This is a government that wants tax and spending cuts when people need help most. The 'invisible hand', takes fags out of people's mouths, it's government's duty to put money back in their pockets - without sounding like a Pinko, we know that unfettered capitalism has a tendency of shitting on people.

Fin.

Monday, 24 November 2008

Reflections on the PBR

If pre-budget reports generate this type of interest then god knows what will happen with next spring's budget. Will set 3 PSHE (year 8) bring it up in lesson; will my most challenging pupils question the government's fiscal stimulus?

Apart from being a rather amusing euphemism, the 'fiscal stimulus' announced by Darling today (no 'Blackadder' jokes please) and the whole PBR are significant on any number of levels.

Of course, we're in the middle of the gravest financial crisis since the end of the Second World War (when Mr. Keynes went to Washington and the country was nearly declared bankrupt). However, that said, the proposals outlined today are very interesting in ideological terms and have ensured that the battle lines are well and truly laid for the next General Election (whenever that may be).

Ideologically the most striking element of the report is the creation of a new 45% tax bracket for those earning over £150,000. For 11 years in power, New Labour has been reluctant to use Old Labour ideas re: the redistribution of wealth. Blair and co. have followed Thatcher's mantra on that one - you work hard, your earn your wage and you deserve to keep it. However, what Darling has done today is introduce some old fashioned socialism - the taxes of the rich will be redistributed to the less well off. This token gesture will do little to alleviate the inequalities of welath that have developed over the past three Labour governments. Politically, however, the Chancellor may have found the golden bullet for victory at the next Election. Old reds will, of course, say that he had hitherto failed to see the wood for the trees...either way the left is winning the argument hands down.

Most analyists agree that today Darling has taken a huge gamble. For the first time in years there is clear blue water between the two major parties. They differ on traditional policies of tax and spend and will present two very different manifestos to the public in 2009/10. The Chancellor will be praying that his prediction for an upturn in the economy (supposedly next year) actually happens, otherwise George Osborne will be sending out the bills.

The Tories have reverted to old fiscal conservative ideas - a major threat to Cameron's compassionate conservative public relations bandwagon (Est. 2005). The trouble is, conservatives can't bring themselves to stomach the projected levels of public debt that Labour plans will have generated by 2010. They have therefore shrunk from standing 'shoulder to shoulder' with the government and Brown now derides them as being perhaps the only major political party in the world which opposes the bail out plan offered by himself and other western governments. The Tories' big problem is that they fail to recognise that it isn't necessarily a disaster to run a deficit-based economy (even if those deficits, admittedly, are projected to reach £100 bn). Yes, long term, this will mean an increase in taxes - however, the Tories fail to see short term problems (that's why they're called the nasty party) - help the poor now, in part by a redistribution of wealth, allow everyone to get rich again and the economy to improve and then pay for it when 'the sun is shining' (with measured tax increases, rather than a 'bombshell' - that's old fashioned scarmongering and playing politics...)

If you think about it - 'social progress' or whatever you want to call it, requires considerable debt. You need to spend more so people will become 'better producers' and economic growth results. If you spend roughly the same amount in as you receive in tax receipts then there is a very clear danger of stagnation. Where's the incentive for growth? This is the very essence of progressive politics.

Was Brown too easy with the cash last year and the year before when the sun was shining? Maybe. That doesn't mean that present difficulties are not being solved in a sensible way.

Hurrah for socialism - back on the agenda!